Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Monona Menus

  • Slide 1 of 4
  • Slide 2 of 4
  • Slide 3 of 4
  • Slide 4 of 4

    • Specials

    • The Luck Charm

      Everything Bagel Crust, House Made Well's Farm Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Pickle Red Onion, Spicy Brown Mustard, Swiss and Mozzarella Cheeses, finished with Chives

      16" Pie $27

      10" Pie $17

      10" GF Pie $19

    • 16

      16" 1-Topping Deal (TUESDAY ONLY)

      Our Classic Tomato Pie is the base for your selection of toppings. Every Classic has Romano, Mozzarella, Red Sauce, and Basil unless otherwise specified. Get one topping for free! (delivery/pickup only)

      $16

    Kids' Menu

    • Kids Cheese Pizza

      Our Classic Tomato Pie, with Cheese on Top and no Basil

      $11

    • Popcorn Chicken

      6 Ounces of Hand-Breaded Chicken, Deep Fried and served with Potato Wedges and Smoked Paprika Ranch

      $8

    • Grilled Cheese

      Texas Toast and Provolone Cheese, served with Potato Wedges and Smoked Paprika Ranch

      $7

    • Fish Sticks

      Hand-breaded Sliced Cod, served with Potato Wedges, Smoked Paprika Ranch, and Tartar Sauce

      $9

    Salads

    • Caesar Salad

      Caesar Salad

      Romaine, SarVecchio Parmesan Crisps, House Caesar Dressing & Fresh Dill

      $10

    • Market Salad

      Mixed Greens, Chioggia Beets, Beauty Heart Radish, Purple Daikon, Red Onion, Fennel, Mozzarella Balls with a Balsamic Vinaigrette.

      $9

    Appetizers

    • Chicken Wings

      Chicken Wings

      A Pound of Delicious Wings Available in Buffalo, Korean BBQ or Sriracha Dry Rub. Served with Celery and Blue Cheese Dressing

      $15.50

    • Cheddar Cheese Curds

      Cheddar Cheese Curds

      Half pound of Breaded Cheese Curds garnished with Scallion and served with a side of Smoke Paprika Ranch.

      $10

    • Buffalo Cheddar Cheese Curds

      Half pound of Breaded Cheese Curds tossed and a Sriracha Dry Rub garnished with Scallion and served with a side of Smoke Paprika Ranch

      $10

    • Flying Flowers

      Flying Flowers

      Battered & Fried Cauliflower "Wings". Available in Buffalo, Korean BBQ or Sriracha Dry Rub. Served with Celery & Blue Cheese Dressing

      $9

    • Fried Calamari

      Fried Calamari

      Crispy Fried Squid & Fried Market Vegetables. Served with Lemon Aioli & Marinara, Lemon and Chive

      $16

    • Garlic Bread

      Garlic Bread

      Baguette, Garlic Butter, Sartori SarVecchio & served with House-Made Marinara

      $8

    • House Meatballs

      House Meatballs

      Five Well's Farm Beef, Veal, and Pork Meatballs, Marinara, Sartori Sar Vecchio, with Fresh Herbs & a Toasted Baguette

      $11

    • House Vegan Meatballs

      Five House Made Vegan Meatballs, Marinara, Vegan Mozzarella, Fresh Herbs & a Toasted Baguette

      $16

    • Roasted Carrot Hummus

      Roasted Carrot Hummus with Veggies and Tortilla Chips (Vegan & GF)

      $9

    House Made Pasta Dishes

    • Creamy Woodsman Rigatoni Bake

      Creamy Woodsman Rigatoni Bake

      House- Made Rigatoni, Woodsman Mushroom Mix, Béchamel Sauce, Mozzarella/Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese Mix. Finished with an herb mélange of Fresh Basil, Oregano and Parsley. ** Feeds 2/3 People **

      $15

    • Lasagna

      Lasagna

      House Recipe Sausage, Red Sauce, Fresh Basil, Mozzarella/Romano/Ricotta Cheese Blend & Fresh Spinach ** Feeds 2-3 People **

      $18

    Subs/Sandwiches

    • Fish Sandwich

      A quarter pound of Cod, lightly breaded and deep fried, with provolone, tartar, and lettuce, on a Stalzy's bun

      $11

    • Meatball Sub

      Meatball Sub

      House made with Wells Farms Beef, Garlic Butter, Provolone and Red Sauce on a Madison Sourdough Hoagie Roll.

      $11.50

    • Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich

      Tender Chicken Thigh, breaded and deep-fried, then dipped in our Nashville Hot Sauce. Served on grilled Texas Toast, with slaw, pickles, and Garlic Aioli.

      $12

    • The Silvio Sandwich

      The Silvio Sandwich

      Spicy Boars Head Capicola, Soppressata, and Ham, layered thick on a Madison Sourdough's Italian Deli Bread. Topped with sliced provolone, shredded lettuce, sliced tomato, sliced red onion, banana pepper, red wine vinegar and olive oil.

      $14

    • Sundried Tomato Chicken Sandwich

      Lightly-breaded and Fried Chicken Thigh, on Madison Sourdough Italian Deli Roll, with Sundried Tomato Pesto Aioli, Lettuce, Provolone Cheese, and Bacon.

      $11

    • Vegan Meatball Sub

      House made with Impossible Meat, Garlic Oil, Vegan Mozzarella and Red Sauce on a Madison Sourdough Italian Deli Roll.

      $13

    Desserts

    • Chocolate Cake

      Chocolate Cake

      A Vegan Cake with Dark Chocolate Ganache, Coconut Caramel & Whipped Cream

      $7

    • Tiramisu

      Espresso-Dipped Ladyfingers, Mascarpone Cheese & Chocolate Sauce

      $7

    • Cheesecake

      Mascarpone Cheesecake topped with a Strawberry Sauce made from Dane County Farmers Market Strawberries

      $9

    Specialty Pies

    In 10" or 16" sizes
    • Tomato Pie

      Tomato Pie

      The classic, but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, in 1910

      16" Pie $16

      10" Pie $11

      10" GF Pie $13

    • Figgettaboudit

      Chef Adam loves Brussels Sprouts. He also loves our Fig and Bacon Pizza. He had a crazy idea and now we have the best of both worlds. Whole Milk Mozzarella, Wine Poached Mission Figs, Fried Shaved Brussels Sprouts, Bacon, & Gorgonzola Cheese, finished with Balsamic Red Wine Reduction & Fresh Basil

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • Fat Uncle Tony

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni & Red Sauce finished with Fresh Basil

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • Fig and Bacon

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Wine Poached Mission Figs, Bacon & Gorgonzola Cheese, finished with Balsamic Red Wine Reduction & Fresh Basil

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • Jimmy Knock-Off

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, House Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Fresh Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Goat Cheese, finished with Hot Honey & Fresh Basil

      16: Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • Phoning It In

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Red Sauce, Pepperoni, Mushroom, Yellow Onion, Green & Banana Peppers & Fresh Basil

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • Seoul Eater

      Seoul Eater

      Mozzarella, Korean BBQ, Chicken, Duck Fat & Chili Marinated Broccoli, Red Pepper, Yellow Onion. Garnished with Scallions.

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • The Smokeshow

      The Smokeshow

      Smoked Mozzarella, Bacon, Ricotta, Truffle Oil, Oregano, Red Pepper Flake, Scallions and Smoked Paprika

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • The Vegetarian

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Beet Pesto, Brussel Sprouts, Kale, Caramelized Onion, & Goat Cheese, finished with Balsamic Reduction & Fresh Basil

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • The Woodsman

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Crimini, Oyster & Shiitake Mushrooms with Leek, & Pleasant Ridge Reserve, finished with Truffle Oil, Cracked Black Pepper & Chives

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    • Vegan Supreme

      Vegan Mozzarella, Red Sauce, Vegan Italian “Sausage”, Mushroom, Yellow Onion, and Green Pepper, finished with Fresh Basil

      16" Pie $26

      10" Pie $16

      10" GF Pie $18

    • Walter White

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Romano, Lemon Whipped Ricotta, Roasted Garlic, Calabrese Chili Puree, & Lemon Olive Oil, finished with Fresh Basil

      16" Pie $25

      10" Pie $15

      10" GF Pie $17

    Build Your Own Tomato Pie

    Starts with a Tomato Pie; whole milk mozzarella, Romano, and red sauce

    Gluten Free? Almost all of our pizzas can be made gluten free. We’re proud to offer gluten, dairy and egg free crusts from our friends at Schroeter’s Bakery in Milwaukee, WI. GF Pizzas are 10” for just $15! Limit 4 toppings.

    Add Your Favorite Toppings (10” / 16”)

    • Basic Topping

      10" $1

      16" $2

    • Premium Toppings*

      $2

      $3

    • Super Premium Toppings **

      $3

      $5

    Cheese

    • Extra Mozzarella

    • Goat Cheese*

    • Blue Cheese

    • Ricotta

    Protein

    • Anchovies

    • Bacon*

    • Italian Sausage*

    • Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni**

    • Pepperoni

    • Proscuitto**

    Go Vegan

    • Vegan “mozzarella”*

    • Vegan Italian "Sausage"**

    Vegetables

    • Banana Pepper

    • Black Olive

    • Calabrese Chili

    • Caramelized Onion*

    • Cremini Mushrooms*

    • Fresh Basil*

    • Green Olive

    • Green Pepper

    • Jalapeño

    • Kale

    • Red Pepper

    • Roasted Garlic

    • Roasted Tomato

    • Spinach

    • Wine Poached Figs*

    • Yellow Onion

    To help mitigate the effect of rising prices, and to better provide fair wages and benefits to our employees we are including a 3.99% surcharge on credit and debit card transactions

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!

    Reservations

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thanks!