Sun Prairie Menus
Specials
Appetizers
Available open to close-
Farmer John's Cheese Curds
Lightly battered and fried, finished with Scallions and served with Dyno Sauce
$12
-
Burrata
Wisconsin burrata, heirloom tomato, arugula, lemon live oil, blueberry gastrique, Stalzys grilled bread
$14
-
Whipped Ricotta Sourdough
Grilled Madison Sourdough, topped with Whipped Ricotta, Truffle Honey, and Toasted Pistachios, finished with Fresh Parsley
$12
-
Market Salad
Mixed Greens with Seasonal Vegetables, Sartori SarVecchio, and House Seasonal Vinaigrette
$12
Chicken $6
Bacon $2
Wild caught Alaskan Salmon $12
Gulf Shrimp $6
-
Caesar Salad
Romaine, SarVecchio Parmesan Crisps, House Caesar Dressing & Fresh Dill.
$13
Side Anchovies $2
Chicken $6
Bacon $2
Wild caught Alaskan Salmon $12
-
Calamari
Deep Fried Calamari and Market Vegetable served with Lemon Wedges & Red Sauce
$18
-
Smoked Chicken Wings
8 Bone-in Chicken Wings. Choice of House Buffalo Sauce with a side of Blue Cheese OR Szechuan Salt Seasoned Wings tossed in Alabama White BBQ sauce OR Lemon Pepper Seasoning OR Salt and Pepper OR Korean BBQ
$15.50
-
Grandma Aversano's Meatballs
Old family recipe Meatballs in House Red Sauce with SarVecchio & finished with Fresh Parsley. Served with Grilled Bread. (Not GF)
$12
-
French Fries
Lightly Seasoned (Not GF)
$7
Truffled w/ Parmesan $11
-
Grilled Corn
Aksum’s Farm corn, Hook’s 1 year cheddar, onion ash salt, parsley
$13
-
Blistered shishito
Young earth farm shishito pepper, Neuskis bacon, pickled red onion, feta, scallion
$15
Handmade Pasta and Entrees
We hand make all our pasta in-house using Old World techniques.-
Fish Fry
Breaded Bluegill served with Fries, House-made Coleslaw, and House-made Tartar Sauce. Only available on Friday!
$17
-
Bucatini with Meatball
House-made Bucatini Pasta, Family Recipe Meatball, finished with SarVecchio. Served with Grilled Bread (Not GF)
$21
-
Rigatoni Bolognese
Well’s Farm Beef Ragu and House-made Rigatoni Pasta with Whipped Ricotta and finished with Fresh Parsley
$23
Sub GF Pasta $2
-
Summertime in Athens
1/3 Wells Farm beef, pesto aioli, heirloom tomato, spinach, feta cheese, kalamata olives, Stalzys butter bun
$14
Side Salad $0.50
fries $4
truffle fries $4
-
Classic Setup Burger
1/3 lb Wells Farm Beef, Stalzy's Butter Bun, American Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle & Onion. Add Bacon +$2
$12
side salad $5
fries $3
truffle fries $4
-
Grilled Salmon
Wild caught Alaskan King salmon, sesame yogurt, broccoli, arugula, radish
$26
-
The "Silvio" Sandwich
Boars Head Ham, Sopressata, Capicola, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, and Banana Peppers, finished with Oregano and Oil & Vinegar.
$14
side salad $5
fries $3
truffle fries $4
-
Grilled Ribeye
16oz Well’s Farm Ribeye, Seasonal Vegetables, Demi-glace, and Herb Lemon Butter
$47
-
Seared scallops
Wild caught seared scallops, shishito corn succotash, cherry tomato, sorrel, orange gel
$28
-
Shrimp and Chorizo Moqueca
Wild caught gulf shrimp, grilled Spanish chorizo, gemelli, coconut milk, tomato, green bell pepper, cilantro, chili crisp
$26
Kids
12 and Under-
Tomato Pie
House Red Sauce & WI Mozzarella.
$7
-
Mac and Cheese
Macaroni with House Cheese Sauce served with Seasonal Vegetable
$7
-
Chicken Strips
House Breaded Chicken Cutlets served with Fries, Seasonal Vegetable and Ranch Dressing
$7
-
Buttered noodles
Buttered Macaroni served with Seasonal Vegetable
$6
Desserts
-
Cannolis
Crispy cannolis shells, whipped vanilla ricotta filling, chocolate chips, & powdered sugar
$8
-
Chocolate Cake
Chocolate Cake with Dark Chocolate Ganache and Strawberry Compote
$7
-
Butterscotch Budino
House Budino with Caramel and Sea Salt served with a Shortbread Cookie
$9
Build Your Own Tomato Pie
Starts with whole milk mozzarella, romano, house-made red sauce, and fresh basilAdd Your Favorite Toppings (10” / 16”)
-
Basic Topping
10" $1
16" $2
-
Premium Toppings*
$2
$3
-
Super Premium Toppings **
$3
$5
Cheese
-
Gorgonzola
-
Ricotta*
-
Smoked Gouda*
-
Goat Cheese*
-
Extra Mozzarella
Protein
-
Anchovies*
-
Bacon*
-
Chorizo*
-
Egg*
-
Italian Sausage*
-
Nami Moon Chicken*
-
Nduja Artisans Uncured Pepperoni**
-
Pepperoni
-
Prosciutto**
Go Vegan
-
Vegan “mozzarella”**
-
Vegan Italian Sausage**
Vegetables
-
Arugula*
-
Banana Pepper
-
Black Olive
-
Calabrese Chili
-
Caramelized Onion*
-
Chives
-
Cremini Mushroom*
-
Figs**
-
Fresh Basil
-
Green Olive
-
Green Pepper
-
House Pesto*
-
Jalapeño
-
Red Onion
-
Roasted Garlic
-
Spinach*
-
Tomato
-
Yellow Onion
Specialty Pies
-
Tomato Pie
The classic built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce; finished with Fresh Basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, in 1910
$11.50
$17
-
Fat Uncle Tony
Whole Milk Mozzarella, House Red Sauce, Italian Sausage, Bacon and Pepperoni finished with Fresh Basil
$15.50
$25.50
-
Terrance’s Favorite
Whole Milk Mozzarella, House Red Sauce, Italian Sausage, Roasted Red Pepper, Goat Cheese, and Caramelized Onion finished with Fresh Basil
$15.50
$25.50
-
Woodsman
Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sautéed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, and Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese finished with Truffle Oil, Black Pepper and Fresh Chives.
$15.50
$25.50
-
Figgy Piggy
Whole Milk Mozzarella, Wine Poached Figs, Prosciutto, Pistachios, MontAmore and Bleu Cheese finished with Arugula & Spicy Honey.
$15.50
$25.50
-
Farmer John’s Smoked Gouda
Whole Milk Mozzarella, Heirloom Tomato, Bacon, Mushroom, Roasted Garlic, Smoked Gouda, and Caramelized Onion finished with Fresh Basil
$15
$25
-
Vegan Supreme
Vegan "Mozzarella", Red Sauce, Vegan Italian "Sausage", Cremini Mushroom, Yellow Onion, Green Pepper, Banana Pepper, and Black Olive finished with Fresh Basil
$16.50
$26.50
-
Joey Bananas
Whole Milk Mozzarella, Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Sartori MontAmore, Jalapeño, and Banana Peppers finished with Spicy Honey and Fresh Basil
$15.50
$25.50
-
East Coast Rocker
Whole Milk Mozzarella, Spinach, Ricotta, Sliced Garlic, Chili Flake and Olive Oil finished with Fresh Thyme
$15.50
$25.50
-
Forza
Whole Milk Mozzarella, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Smoked Gouda, Roasted Tomato, Roasted Garlic, Calabrese Chili, and Ricotta, finished with Fresh Basil
$16.50
$26.50
-
Chicken Parmesan
Whole Milk Mozzarella, House-made Pesto, Red Sauce, Braised Nami Moon Chicken, and Sartori Sarvecchio, finished with Toasted Breadcrumb and Fresh Parsley
$16.50
$26.50
-
El Santo
WI Mozzarella, Hook's 1 Year cheddar, chili aioli, jalapeno, chorizo, yellow onion, tomato, corn, cilantro, black pepper
$16.50
$26.50
Gluten Free? Almost all of our pizzas can be made gluten free. We’re proud to offer gluten, dairy and egg free crusts from our friends at Schroeter’s Bakery in Milwaukee, WI.
To help mitigate the effects of inflation and increasing merchant transaction fees, we are now adding a 3.99% service fee on all credit and debit card transactions.
Draft Beer
Ask about our rotating craft beer selectionPackaged Beer
-
Hamm's (16oz)
$4
-
New Belgium - Fruit Smash Seltzer
Variety pack available
$6
-
Loon Juice - Grow a Pear Cider
$6
-
Bells - Amber
$5
-
Lakefront - New Grist
Gluten Free Pilsner
$6
-
Youngblood - Bathtub Bier
Munich Style Helles Lager
$10
-
Rhinegeist Truth
IPA
$8
-
Whole Hog JP Casper White Stout
$7
-
Mobcraft - Low pHunk
Sour Ale
$6
-
Raised Grain Paradocs Red (16oz)
Imperial Red IPA
$10
-
Door County - Dark Skies
Dark Lager
$8
-
Toppling Goliatj - Pseudo Sue (16oz)
American Pale Ale
$10
-
3 Floyd's - Speed Castle
World Ending Pilsner
$7
-
Downeast - Blackberry Cider
$9
-
Blakes - El Chavo
Habenaro & Mango Cider
$8
-
Lake Louie - Barrel Aged Warped Speed
Scotch Ale Aged in Bourbon Barrels
$12
-
Mobcraft - Low pHunk
Sour Ale
$6
-
Tyranena Chief Blackhawk Porter
$6
-
Sal's Pale Ale 4 pack/ Individual cans
available for carryout
$12
$6
-
Third Space - Heavenly Haze
Hazy IPA
$7
Cocktails
-
Retired Emo Kid
State Line London dry gin, simple syrup, Fernet Branca Herbsaint, bitters
$9
-
Sugar, We're going down
JK William grapefruit gin, Tattersall Amaro, Rosemary honey, lemon
$9
-
Traditional Old Fashioned
Choice of Larceny Bourbon, Sal's Wollersheim Press House brandy, or Sal's Limousine Rye +3 Made in the pre-prohibition style without fruit or a carbonated mixer
$9
-
Rhubarb Cosmo
Wheatly vodka, house-made rhubarb syrup, clockwork orange, lime, float of Gosling's 151 rum
$11
-
Hey Bartender!
State Line London dry gin, simple, Fernet Branca Herbsaint, bitters
$10
-
Poblano Blackberry Marg
Lunazul Reposado tequila, Fruitful blackberry liqueurm Ancho Reyes chile liqueur, lime, Tajin rim
$11
-
Hemingway Daiquiri
Plantation 3 star, Maraschino liqueur, lime, grapefruit
$8
-
Jack's Shifty
Larceny Small Batch Bourbon, Laird's AppleJack, clockwork orange, Bogart's bitters
$10
-
Mexican Firing Squad Special
Lunazul Reposado, house-made pomegranate, grenadine, bitters, lime
$8
-
Sippin Pretty
Don Q Crystal rum, Tattersall toasted coconut aquavit, pineapple, mint, simple, lime
$10
-
Madison Smash
Sal's Wollersheim Press House Brandy. lemon, orange, vanilla bark bitters
$9.50
-
White Linen
State Line London dry gin, fresh cucumber, Thatcher's elderflower liqueur, simple, lemon
$9
-
Lion's Tail
Four Roses Bourbon, simple lemon, pimento dram, lime, bitters
$9
-
Wisco Old Fashioned
Choice of Larceny Bourbon, Sal's Wollersheim Press House Brandy, or Sal's Limousine Rye +3 cherry, orange, sugar, bitters, lemon-lime soda
$9
-
Whiskey Smash
Four Roses bourbon, simple lemon, mint
$9.50
-
Ranch Water
Lunazul Reposado tequila, lime, San Pellegrino sparkling mineral water, Tajin rim
$9
-
Jack Rose
Lairds Apple Brandy, house-made pomegranate grenadine, lemon
$10
-
Mango Mule
Wheatly Vodka, Wray & Nephew overproof rum, Fruitful mango liqueur, ginger beer, habanero bitters, lime
$10
White Wine
-
Wollersheim Prairie Fume TAP
2021, Wisconsin
Carafe $42
8oz $11
5oz $7
-
RELAX, Reisling
2021, Germany
Bottle $32
8oz $13
5oz $8
-
Lagaria, Pinot Grigio
2021, Italy
Bottle $40
8oz $16
5oz $10
-
Fresh Vine, Chardonnay
2019, CA
Bottle $40
8oz $14
5oz $9
-
Shannon Ridge, Sauvignon Blanc
2022, Lake County, CA
Bottle $40
8oz $16
5oz $10
-
Honoro Vera Rose
2021, Jamilla, Spain
Bottle $36
8oz $14
5oz $9
-
Reywood, Moscato
2022, Central Coat, CA
Bottle $36
8oz $13
5oz $8
-
Moletto, Prosecco
NV, Italy
Bottle $32
8oz $13
5oz $8
Red Wine
-
Perrin Cotes du Rhone, Red Blend (TAP)
2019 Rhone, France
Carafe $42
8oz $11
5oz $7
-
Cloudline, Pinot Noir
2020, Mendoza Argentina
Bottle $48
8oz $19
5oz $12
-
Ceibo, Malbec
2020 Mendoza, Argentina
Bottle $48
8oz $19
5oz $12
-
Wente, Carbernet Sauvignon
2020, Central Coast CA
Bottle $44
8oz $18
5oz $11
-
Sand Point, Carbernet Sauvignon
2020, CA
Bottle $32
8oz $13
5oz $8
-
Querceto Chianti
2019 Chianti, Italy
Bottle $40
8oz $16
5oz $10
-
Caymus, Cabernet Sauvignon
2020, Napa, CA
Bottle $128
Join us for Happy Hour from 4p-6p Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and now Sunday! Buy one-get one select tap beers, and tap wines. $5 off any 10" specialty pies, when sitting at the RED barstools ONLY(no exceptions).
TUESDAY:
16" Tomato pie with One free Topping for $16
THURSDAYS:
Thursday Friends and Family Combo! Get a Large (16") 2-Topping Pie, Small Market Salad, Choice of Pound of Wings (choose your sauce) with a 2-Liter of Soda for only $38
Carryout & Delivery only.
Cannot combine deals with other offers or coupons.
SUN PRAIRIE SALVATORE'S RESTAURANT WEEK 2023
7/23/23-7/28/23
$30 Three Course Dinner
⇹
Starter (Choose One)
Market Salad- Vitruvian Farms greens, seasonal vegetables, Sarvecchio, citrus vinaigrette
Grilled Corn-Aslum Farm grilled corn, calabrese chili butter, Hook's 1 Year cheddar, onion ash salt, parsley
Burrata-WI burrata, salsa verde, heirloom tomato, arugula, grilled bread, pea shoot
⇹
Main (Choose One)
10” Portuguesa Pie-Grilled chorizo, smoked tomato sauce, cherry tomato, roasted red pepper, yellow onion, arugula
Shrimp Moqueca-Wild caught Gulf shrimp, grilled chorizo, house-made gemelli pasta, tomato, green pepper, coconut milk, chili crisp, cilantro
Roasted Chicken-Roasted chicken breast, corn, red pepper, cherry tomato, arugula, poblano crema, lemon honey vinagrette, goat cheese
⇹
Dessert (Choose One)
Passion Fruit Mousse-Passion Fruit, whipped cream, basil
Chocolate Cake- Door County cherry compote
Butterscotch Budino-Caramel, sea salt, shortbread cookie
Available 4pm-9pm Sunday and Tuesday -Friday 7/23-7/28